One of language is means used for transfering thoughts from one mind to another. Based on this definition, possibility animal is have a language, the animal is communication with each other used sounds and limited gesture for sending the message, but they cant speak. Each kind has certain number of inborn signals or expressing it’s feelings but these aren’t words, all of human use language for express their feelings and emotion but the animal isn’t.
According in Wikipedia.org there are several properties of language that makes different between human language and animal communication system:
- Arbitaries: No rational realtionship between a sound or sign and it’s meaning.
- Cultural Transmission: consicius or not, lnguage is passed from one language user to the net.
- Discretennes: To create meaning , language is composed from combinations and features units.
- Discplacement: Language is not limited to last, here and now, not in the spatially or temporally vicinity.
- Duality: Language works on to level at once, a surface level and semantic level.
- Metalinguistics: Ability to discuss language itself.
- Productivity: Language can be used to crate an indefinty large of number of utterances.
Thomas. A. Soebok is argue not to using “language” terms in nimal communication system, because language is have evolutionary continuumon communication methods of animal language system and human language system. The result of this experiment will describe how incredible of humn language evolution and also will indicate the weakness of animal language theory.
Language is one of element to a nation culture development but the animal can’t advanced their civilization, its because they don’t have a language but only have a animal communication system (pra-language). Most of animal doing their activity and communication without thingking before, because they don’t have sense but only have instinct it’s very different with human language system. So, Its indicate that the animal is’nt have language.
In addition, animal communication system isn’t creative and not productive , also without infinite variety through of language, for example a native english speaker can talk in many different language, like spanish, japaneese and etc but if we compare with animal capability to transfer another animal language, like monkey can’t understand what other animal communication and vice versa.
According in Wikipedia.org there are several properties of language that makes different between human language and animal communication system:
- Arbitaries: No rational realtionship between a sound or sign and it’s meaning.
- Cultural Transmission: consicius or not, lnguage is passed from one language user to the net.
- Discretennes: To create meaning , language is composed from combinations and features units.
- Discplacement: Language is not limited to last, here and now, not in the spatially or temporally vicinity.
- Duality: Language works on to level at once, a surface level and semantic level.
- Metalinguistics: Ability to discuss language itself.
- Productivity: Language can be used to crate an indefinty large of number of utterances.
Thomas. A. Soebok is argue not to using “language” terms in nimal communication system, because language is have evolutionary continuumon communication methods of animal language system and human language system. The result of this experiment will describe how incredible of humn language evolution and also will indicate the weakness of animal language theory.
Language is one of element to a nation culture development but the animal can’t advanced their civilization, its because they don’t have a language but only have a animal communication system (pra-language). Most of animal doing their activity and communication without thingking before, because they don’t have sense but only have instinct it’s very different with human language system. So, Its indicate that the animal is’nt have language.
In addition, animal communication system isn’t creative and not productive , also without infinite variety through of language, for example a native english speaker can talk in many different language, like spanish, japaneese and etc but if we compare with animal capability to transfer another animal language, like monkey can’t understand what other animal communication and vice versa.
